Yellow road signs pointing in opposite directions, one reading PANIC and the other CALM, against a blue sky

What Should You Do If Your Rehab Exercises Hurt?

Should Rehab Exercises Hurt?

By Dr. Deborah Morrone, D.C.

Last updated: November 20, 2026

You start your exercises, something twinges, and you freeze. Is that normal? Are you making it worse? Should you push through or stop?

For a long time, the standard advice was simple: if it hurts, don’t do it.

The research since then has made the answer more interesting — and more useful. Pain during rehab is information, not always a warning. What matters is how much pain, what kind of pain, and what happens afterward.

The short version: Some pain during rehab exercise is usually OK — and avoiding all pain can slow you down. Studies comparing painful and pain-free exercise for chronic muscle and joint pain found no clear advantage either way, and a trial of early rehab after muscle injury found that starting gentle movement on day 2 instead of day 9 got athletes back about three weeks sooner. The guide we use in the clinic is a traffic light: green and yellow mean the pain is safe to work through; red means stop and get checked.

Should rehab exercises hurt?

Not necessarily — but some discomfort may be expected after an injury, or if you haven’t moved a muscle or joint for a long time. It doesn’t always mean the exercise or movement is bad or causing harm.

Studies comparing exercise programs that allowed some pain with programs that stayed pain-free found no clear advantage either way — and a 2025 update concluded that pain during exercise “may not need to be avoided” to get better (Smith et al., 2017; Tran et al., 2025).

So the research does not say pain is good for you. It says that some pain during exercise, kept within limits, did not lead to worse outcomes — and that waiting until everything is pain-free before you start moving can cost you strength and time.

The real question is not “does it hurt?” but “how much, what kind, and what happens next?”

How soon should I start moving after an injury?

Sooner than most people think — gently, and with guidance. In one study, athletes who started rehab 2 days after a muscle injury got back to sport about three weeks sooner than those who waited 9 days, with no more reinjuries (Bayer et al., 2017).

It was a small study, so that is a signal, not the last word. And “early” did not mean jumping straight back into full training — the first week was gentle stretching, with the load built up gradually.

Early movement is not the same as pushing hard early. Our guide to managing muscle strains walks through the PEACE & LOVE approach we use in those first days and weeks.

The reason early, gentle movement helps is straightforward: muscles and joints that don’t move become weak and stiff and tight, ultimately leading to another type of pain and problem. Rest has its place in the first day or two. After that, the aim is to find the level of movement the injured area can tolerate and build from there.

How do I know when to do more?

Pain alone is a poor gauge for progression. Research on hamstring rehab backs that up: the programs that tested strength got people back fastest, and allowing some pain during rehab built stronger hamstrings than staying completely pain-free (Hickey et al., 2017; Hickey et al., 2020).

That is how we think about progression in the clinic: pain is one input, but strength, range of motion, and what you can actually do matter at least as much. If you are waiting for zero pain before you do more, you may be waiting longer than you need to — and losing strength while you wait. Our hamstring strain page covers how we approach that injury, and our strength and mobility work is built into care plans for the same reason: strength is part of the treatment, not something you add on at the end.

Not all pain is the same

Here is the part that changes everything: pain is not one thing. The framework we use to sort it out comes from Annie O’Connor and colleagues, described in their book A World of Hurt: A Guide to Classifying Pain.

In plain terms, the system sorts pain into a few kinds:

  • Pain from irritated tissue — a muscle, joint, or tendon that is inflamed or overloaded. This is the most common kind, and it usually responds to graded loading: the right amount of movement, built up over time.
  • Pain from an irritated nerve — burning, tingling, or shooting pain that follows a nerve’s path. Nerves need a different kind of care than muscles do, and stretching a sensitized nerve the way you would stretch a tight muscle can make it worse.
  • Pain where the nervous system has turned the volume up — pain that has been going on long enough that the system itself becomes more sensitive, so that ordinary movement hurts more than the tissue damage alone would explain. This kind needs education and graded exposure alongside movement, not just hands-on care.
  • Pain shaped by mood, stress, and sleep — the same injury hurts more when you are exhausted, stressed, or sleeping badly. That does not make the pain “in your head.” It makes it whole-person, which is why sleep and stress are part of the conversation in our office.

The full system has more detail than this — and it is a tested one: trained therapists can place nearly all patients into these categories (Kolski et al., 2016). The practical point for you is simpler: the kind of pain you have changes what you should do about it. That is why two people with the same diagnosis can get different exercise plans, and why “just rest it” or “just push through it” are both too simple on their own.

The traffic light we use in the clinic

This is the guide we give patients for judging pain during activity. It comes from A World of Hurt (Kolski & O’Connor, 2023). What sets the light is how much the pain goes up, how long it takes to settle, and whether you lose strength or range of motion.

LightWhat it looks likeWhat to do
🟢 Green — Safe Pain — No HarmPain increases a little with activity (3-5/10) but improves within a few hours. No decrease in strength or range of motion.Keep going — gradually increase the duration and intensity of your activities.
🟡 Yellow — Safe Pain — Hurt Does Not Equal HarmPain is 5-6/10 (“hurts but I can move”) and decreases within a day or two. No significant changes in strength or range of motion.Modify activities and rest as needed. Keep moving and stay as active as you can.
🔴 Red — STOP.Pain spikes and/or is more than 7/10. Or severe pain persists more than 48 hours after activity.Stop the activity and contact us for advice.

Adapted from: A World of Hurt: A Guide to Classifying Pain by Melissa C. Kolski & Annie O’Connor.

The numbers are a guide, not a rule — the real question the traffic light asks is not just “what number is it now?” but “what happens afterward?” If pain settles within a few hours, the load was tolerated. If it is still up after a day or two, ease back. If severe pain persists more than 48 hours, or you have lost strength or range of motion, that is the signal to stop and get reassessed.

For the soreness that shows up a day or two after a workout — the stiff, achy feeling in the muscles you worked — that is usually delayed-onset muscle soreness, and it is a different thing from rehab pain. Our post on what “good” pain is covers how to tell the two apart.

The talk test: how hard are you working?

The traffic light tells you about pain. The talk test tells you about effort — and we use them together. It is the simplest exertion gauge there is, from the CDC:

  • Light effort: you can talk and sing easily.
  • Moderate effort: you can talk, but not sing. On a 0-to-10 effort scale, this is about a 5 or 6.
  • Vigorous effort: you can only say a few words before pausing for breath. About a 7 or 8 on the effort scale.

No watch, no app, no heart-rate strap needed — and it is not thrown off by medicines that affect heart rate. For most rehab and general conditioning, moderate effort is the sweet spot: you are working hard enough to adapt, but you can still breathe and talk. If you cannot get a sentence out, you have moved into vigorous territory, which has its place — but probably not on the day you are testing a sore knee.

When should I get checked?

Most rehab pain is green or yellow, and flare-ups are a normal part of the process — a flare-up is a signal to adjust the plan, not proof that the care has failed. But get checked promptly if you notice any of these:

  • Pain that spikes during activity, or goes above 7 out of 10 (a red light)
  • Severe pain that persists more than 48 hours after activity
  • A loss of strength or range of motion after an activity
  • New or worsening numbness, tingling, or weakness in a limb
  • Pain after a significant fall or injury, or pain that keeps getting worse despite rest and simple care
  • Changes in bladder or bowel function along with back pain

Those signs change what needs to be examined first. And if you are unsure whether what you are feeling is green, yellow, or red, that is exactly the kind of question to bring to your visit — it takes a minute to sort out in person, and it is much harder to guess at home.

Frequently asked questions

Should rehab exercises hurt?

Not necessarily — but they don’t have to be pain-free. Studies comparing painful and pain-free exercise for chronic muscle and joint pain found no clear advantage either way, and a 2025 update concluded that pain during exercise may not need to be avoided. Some pain during rehab, kept within limits, did not lead to worse outcomes. The point is not that pain is good — it is that some pain is not automatically a stop sign.

How much pain is OK during exercise?

Use the traffic light. Green is pain up a little (3-5 out of 10) that improves within a few hours, with no decrease in strength or range of motion. Yellow is pain at 5-6 out of 10 that decreases within a day or two — it hurts, but you can move. Red is pain that spikes and/or goes above 7 out of 10, any sharp, stabbing, or intolerable pain that changes how you move, or severe pain that persists more than 48 hours after activity — stop and contact us.

How soon after an injury should I start exercising?

Sooner than most people think, gently. In a 2017 trial, athletes who started rehab 2 days after a muscle injury returned to sport about three weeks sooner than those who waited 9 days. Early does not mean hard — the first week was gentle stretching, with load built up in stages. If you are unsure where your starting point is, get assessed first.

What if my pain is worse the next day?

That is the traffic light’s key question. If pain improves within a few hours, the load was tolerated — a green response. If it decreases within a day or two, that is yellow: modify activities, rest as needed, and keep moving. If severe pain persists more than 48 hours, or you have lost strength or range of motion, that is red — stop and contact us.

Does pain during exercise mean I’m causing damage?

Usually not. Pain is a poor measure of tissue damage — the level of pain you feel does not reliably tell you how much harm is being done. That is one of the myths we address in our post on 7 myths about chronic pain. What matters more is the pattern: whether pain settles afterward, and whether your strength and range of motion are holding up or improving.

When should I stop exercising and get checked?

Stop and get checked if you have pain that spikes during activity or goes above 7 out of 10; a sharp, stabbing, or intolerable pain that changes how you move; a loss of strength or range of motion; severe pain that persists more than 48 hours after activity; new numbness or weakness; or pain after a significant injury. When in doubt, bring it to your visit — it is a quick question to sort out in person.

Ready to start moving and feeling better?

If you’re unsure about what you can and can’t do, book an assessment at start.frederickchiro.com or call or text us at (301) 695-0032. We’ll sort out what kind of pain it is, find the level of movement you can tolerate, and build from there.

This article is general education about pain and rehabilitation. It is not personalized medical advice; talk with your own providers about your symptoms and options.

References

  1. Smith BE, Hendrick P, Smith TO, Bateman M, Moffatt F, Rathleff MS, Selfe J, Logan P. Should exercises be painful in the management of chronic musculoskeletal pain? A systematic review and meta-analysis. Br J Sports Med. 2017;51(23):1679–1687. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2016-097383 (PMID 28596288)
  2. Tran I, Gibbs MT, Yu N, Powell JK, Smith BE, Jones MD. Effectiveness of painful versus nonpainful exercise on pain intensity, disability, and other patient-reported outcomes in adults with chronic musculoskeletal pain: an updated systematic review with meta-analysis. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2025;55(8):1–11. doi:10.2519/jospt.2025.13253 (PMID 40699606)
  3. Bayer ML, Magnusson SP, Kjaer M, for the Tendon Research Group Bispebjerg. Early versus delayed rehabilitation after acute muscle injury. N Engl J Med. 2017;377:1300–1301. doi:10.1056/NEJMc1708134 (PMID 28953439) — letter to the editor reporting a randomized trial.
  4. Hickey JT, Timmins RG, Maniar N, Williams MD, Opar DA. Criteria for progressing rehabilitation and determining return-to-play clearance following hamstring strain injury: a systematic review. Sports Med. 2017;47(7):1375–1387. doi:10.1007/s40279-016-0667-x (PMID 28035586)
  5. Hickey JT, Timmins RG, Maniar N, Rio E, Hickey PF, Pitcher CA, Williams MD, Opar DA. Pain-free versus pain-threshold rehabilitation following acute hamstring strain injury: a randomized controlled trial. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2020;50(2):91–103. doi:10.2519/jospt.2020.8895 (PMID 32005093)
  6. Kolski MC, O’Connor A, Van Der Laan K, Lee J, Kozlowski AJ, Deutsch A. Validation of a pain mechanism classification system (PMCS) in physical therapy practice. J Man Manip Ther. 2016;24(4):192–199. doi:10.1179/2042618614Y.0000000090 (PMID 27582618)
  7. Kolski M, O’Connor A. A World of Hurt: A Guide to Classifying Pain. World of Hurt LLC; 2023. — source of the traffic-light guide and PMCS framework.
  8. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. How to Measure Physical Activity Intensity (the talk test). cdc.gov/physical-activity-basics

Share this post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *